Analysis of the story "Innocent" - Any essay on a topic. "Philosophical reflections of Voltaire in the story" Simpleton Innocent main characters

Analysis of the story "Innocent"

Philosophical tale"Innocent" first saw the light in 1767. In it, Voltaire addressed the problem of the rigidity of social moral norms that existed during the period of prosperity of French absolutism. The central figure that comes into conflict with modernity, the author makes " natural man» Rousseau is a twenty-two-year-old youth, French by birth, but Huron by upbringing.

Raised among wild Canadian Indians main character the story is speaking name- Innocent. So the hero was named in England for his sincerity and actions performed on the basis of "natural", and not invented by society, legislative law. In the first half of the story artistic image The Innocent has a pronounced comic character. A young man, guided by a direct perception of the world, wants to be baptized in the river, as they did biblical characters from the “New Testament” he read, dreams of a wedding with his godmother, the lovely Saint-Yves, and does not want to understand why he cannot marry a girl who agrees to become his wife. The second half of the work makes the Innocent a tragic figure. Having joined the sciences and arts in prison, the young man, without losing his natural kindness, begins to penetrate into the essence of the French society around him.

Several chapters describing the development of the protagonist's mental abilities give the story the features of an upbringing novel. Voltaire directly connects the quick and correct perception of cultural and scientific information by the Innocent with his “savage upbringing”, which protected the character from “prejudices”: “He saw things as they are, while we see them all our lives as they are not ".

The philosophy of life is revealed by the French enlightener, to a large extent, through the category of irony. Good-natured humor and harsh satire go hand in hand, making the philosophical story comedic as well. While the image of the young Huron evokes a good-natured, understanding smile in the reader, the description of the representatives of the society of Lower Brittany is perceived as best case, anecdotally. The uncle of the Innocent, the Abbé de Kerkabon, is described by Voltaire as a great lover of reading Rabelais after immersing himself in the works of Blessed Augustine. His sister, a 45-year-old spinster, is portrayed as a woman who is offended by the inattention of men to her - first by English sailors, then by a young Huron. Highly enlightened French society is shown as a noisy gathering of people talking and interrupting each other at the same time.

The only character over whom the author only slightly teases is the beloved of the Innocent, Mademoiselle de Saint-Yves. In the story, she acts as a plot-forming person: the Huron's love for her, his subsequent adventures and her selfless, tragic act become the central point of the narrative, on which all other events are strung. The fall of the girl allows the author to show the true face of French morality: all court positions, all military ranks and awards are bought in it not at the cost of personal dedication, but by the beauty and youth of wives.

The religious and political situation in France late XVII century, is revealed by Voltaire through an episode of a visit by the Innocent to a small, almost depopulated town of Saumur. The Protestants fleeing from it tell the hero about their misadventures and the short-sightedness of the policy of Louis XIV, who decided to support the Pope who hates him, and not his people - albeit of a different faith.

Philosophical story "Innocent" - beautiful literary sample of the Enlightenment, debunking the delusions of his time.

Keep in mind that the story "Innocent" is also known as "The Simpleton". Also, be sure to read other writings on Voltaire.

PRACTICAL COURSE

THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE IDEA OF "NATURAL MAN" IN VOLTAIRE'S STORY "THE SIMPLE MAN"

Plan

1. "Innocent" - Voltaire's philosophical story (history of creation, theme, idea, construction, title of the work).

2. Characteristics of the main character of the Innocent (Huron), features of his worldview.

3. The problem of love in the story. The image of the Saints.

4. The problem of religion and the exposure of the church reaction in the work.

Tasks for the preparatory period

1. Write out quotes to characterize the main character.

2. write out philosophical thoughts from the work.

Literature

1. Eremenko O. V. Defender of natural human rights. Materials for the study of Voltaire's story "The Simpleton". 9 cells // world literature in the middle educational institutions Ukraine. - 1999.-№ 6. - S. 39 - 40.

2. Limborsky I. V. Voltaire and Ukraine // Foreign literature in educational institutions. - 1999. -No. Z, -S. 48-50.

3. Shalaginov B. "Everything is for the best in this best of all possible worlds"? // Foreign literature. - 2000. - No. 15 (175). - S. 1 - 2.

Instructional materials

The action of the story "Innocent" (XVII 67) was completely unfolding in France, although the main character is an Indian from the Huron tribe, who, by coincidence, ended up in Europe.

Despite the rather primitive compositional construction and restrained presentation of thoughts, during the work, its satirical orientation was traced through and through.

In the philosophical stories of Voltaire, in vain, he searched for psychologism, immersion in peace of mind characters, believable depiction of human characters, or a believable plot. The main thing in them is aggravated satirical image social evil, cruelty and senselessness of existing social institutions and relations. This harsh reality tested the real value of the world's philosophical philosophies.

Appeal to reality, to its acute social and spiritual conflicts that permeated all of Voltaire's work - his philosophy, journalism, poetry, prose, dramaturgy. For all its topicality, it penetrated deeply into the essence of universal human problems, which went far beyond the era when the writer himself lived and worked.

The story is built in the form of “adaptation” of a “natural person”, not spoiled by civilization, in the conditions of the then reality, in other words, it is the process of transforming the Innocent into an ordinary person.

"Natural man" - "artificial" man (a product of civilization) - the main contradiction of the work.

In the story "Voltaire" argued with J.-J. Rousseau - the creator of the theory of "natural man" and the harmful effects of civilization on it.

Main character"Philosophical Tale" belonged to the "uncivilized" Indian tribe of the Huroniv and ended up in France by accident. Everything that is familiar to the "civilized" French caused the young man a simple-minded surprise (this is emphasized by the name of the hero).

Focus on those features french life, which, according to the writer, contradicted common sense, the natural nature of man: “His mind, not distorted by mistakes, retained all its natural straightness. He saw things as they really are, while we, under the influence of the views learned in childhood, see them everywhere and always as they never are. The natural mind is higher than the common sense acquired in the conditions of civilization, for the latter is thoroughly poisoned by prejudices. The basis of the comic in the work was precisely the discrepancy between the judgments of the natural mind and common social mores (prejudices).

Voltaire raised the question of the role of church life for the moral state of society, which was covered both in terms of the individual and the entire state, the governing apparatus, and justice.

home story line- the love story of the Simpleton and the young beautiful Saint-Yves. At first, the events took place in Lower Brittany, in the priory of Our Lady of the Mountain. With his naive, but well-aimed judgments, Huron, without knowing it, denounced various social prejudices and stupidities, in particular, people's behavior, based on a literal understanding of religious prescriptions.

In the second half of the work, the Simpleton, having distinguished himself in the battle with the British that attacked the coast, went to Paris for a well-deserved reward, and at the same time for permission to marry his beloved Sainte-Yves. However, "natural reason" could not find common language neither with the "state mind", nor with the "confessional mind". All the officials addressed by the Simpleton, and after him by Saint-Yves, are clerics; the people who surrounded the heroes spoke almost exclusively religious themes and looked at the world through the prism of confessionalism. The whole society is divided into warring religious groups. Here, religiosity arose rather than as a superstition, but as a pragmatic, selfish position that led to personal enrichment. Voltaire sought to show that religiosity does not provide French society with any order, does not make it more moral and happier. The work reflected the atmosphere of those years when most Catholic monarchies began to prohibit the activities of the Jesuits, until the order was completely dissolved by the decision of Pope Clement XIV (XVII 73).

Voltaire was more condescending towards the Jansenists, to whom the learned prisoner Gordon belongs in the story. It sounded ironic that it was in prison, away from scientific centers civilization, under the guidance of a disgraced heretic, the Huron received his thorough knowledge of the world. Sympathetically recalled Voltaire and the Huguenots. Louis XIV, having broken the Edict of Nantes, doomed to exile thousands of industrious and smart people, "many hands that could serve him." Since, according to the writer, natural reason must win, at the end of the work, the Jansenist Gordon "renounced his strict convictions and became a real person."

The story ends tragically for its characters. Small man turned out to be completely defenseless against the arbitrariness of those in power. All her "natural feelings" - integrity, cordiality, faith in justice - are ruthlessly trampled on by the state machine.

The position of the English moralists - Shaftesbury, Richardson, Defoe and others - did not stand the test of Voltaire's sarcasm.

Composition

A significant phenomenon in Voltaire's philosophical prose was the story "The Innocent" (1767). Here the author has taken a big step forward on the path of bringing literature closer to living modernity: events are unfolding in France, they are freed from exotic camouflage. If in Zadige and Candide Voltaire resorted to masking the object of criticism or transferred the action to the East, then in The Innocent he openly speaks about the vices of French society. In this regard, the story is richly saturated with everyday, social details, close to real life. The incriminating pathos of The Innocent One is very strong.

The denunciation goes in the ideological area. Voltaire judges feudal France from the standpoint of an enlightening mind, from the point of view of a man who has not been corrupted by civilization. The thought, characteristic of philosophical stories, of the hostility of feudal relations human personality her natural feelings are brought to the logical limit in "Innocent". The heroes of this work not only suffer, as in "Zadige" and "Candida", they find themselves in tragic situations leading to death.

The story is not built on a clash of characters. In the center of her conflict is a Huron Indian (French by birth) with incomprehensible circumstances hostile to him. European life. feudal; reality gradually reveals its inhuman essence to him. The simple-minded, named Hercules de Kerkabon at baptism, finds himself in comic situations due to the violation of all kinds of social conventions. He judges everything from the point of view of "natural law", not recognizing any moral restrictions (such is his attack on Saint-Yves, caused by the desire to marry her immediately). Voltaire at first good-naturedly makes fun of his hero and at the same time sneers at Rousseau, showing what inconsistencies the behavior of a “natural person” who ignores the mores of a civilized society can lead to.

However, the situation is gradually changing. The simple-hearted is becoming more and more familiar with feudal France. The innocent Sainte-Yves is imprisoned in a monastery. The hero himself, who went to the royal court, ends up in the Bastille. From a comic figure, he turns into a tragic one. All the guilt of the Innocent consisted only in expressing sympathy for the Huguenots. Voltaire not only strikes at the fanaticism of Catholics. In the person of the Reverend Father de la Chaise, he debunks the espionage of the Jesuits, paints terrible pictures of the arbitrariness of lawlessness that reigns in court circles.

To rescue the Innocent from prison, Saint-Yves sacrifices his honor. The moral "fall" has such a strong effect on the psyche of the girl that she dies from unbearable experiences. Saint-Yves is entirely at the mercy of the moral representation of his environment. She considers herself a criminal, not understanding her sacrificial decision. The beautiful Sainte-Yves is a victim not only of the arbitrariness and moral licentiousness that prevails at court, but also of that moral rigorism that was widespread in bourgeois society. Reproaching herself for "cowardice", she "did not realize how much virtue there was in the crime for which she reproached herself."

Characteristically, the Innocent, who is alien to moral prejudices, does not at all consider his bride guilty, for she decided to take her step in the name of love.

The simple-hearted changes in the process of narration. However, the changes do not concern his character (from beginning to end he remains the same in moral and psychological terms), but some forms of his consciousness. It enriches. As a result of his encounter with society, the Innocent becomes more and more enlightened. Conversations with the prisoner of the Bastille, the Jansenist Gordon, were especially helpful for his intellectual development. Huron not only quickly mastered all the subtleties of theology, but subjected it to destructive criticism, and with the help of the simplest logical techniques.

Voltaire and this time approaches the assessment of all phenomena of reality from the point of view of the interests of the individual. His position is especially clearly expressed where Innocent in his reasoning refers to the historical past. “He started reading history books; they made him sad. The world seemed to him too evil and miserable. Indeed, history is nothing but a picture of crimes and misfortunes. A crowd of people, innocent and meek, is invariably lost in obscurity on a vast stage. Only depraved ambitious people turn out to be the actors.

Yet Voltaire, in The Innocent, as in Candide, refrains from the radical conclusions that might follow from that sharp criticism to which he subjected his contemporary society. There is no mention of the need for reorganization in the story. social relations. Voltaire as a whole puts up with the existing system. His Innocent becomes an excellent officer in the royal army. The fate of Gordon is also arranged for the better. The finale of the work is sustained in conciliatory tones. True, criticism persists in last phrase that there are many decent people in the world who, unlike Gordon, could say: "There is no use in misfortune." But nevertheless, reconciliation with the reality of Gordon and the Innocent significantly weakens the general impression of the radicalism of the author's judgments.

In prose, as in drama, Voltaire acts primarily as an exponent of enlightenment views. This largely determines not only the ideological, but also the aesthetic originality of his works. Both its positive and negative characters are rationalistically set, as a rule, they are the personification of certain ideas. Nerestan, Mohammed embody fanaticism, Zaira, Safir - humanity, Brutus - the spirit of republicanism. The same is observed in philosophical stories. But the heroes here are psychologically more complex, although they retain a predominant tendency towards one-sidedness. Zadig, Candide, the Innocent in all trials show their positivity. Only their ideas about life change. In contrast to them, Pangloss and Martin are mask images with a pronounced dominant that are not influenced by social circumstances. Through all the hardships of life, they carry their conviction unchanged, a certain view of the world.

Art is not yet recognized by Voltaire as specific form objective portrayal of life. Artistic creativity he is seen primarily as a means of propagating certain moral and political truths. It performs mainly utilitarian functions. Voltaire the playwright turns goodies into the mouthpieces of their own views. Such, for example, is Orosman, who expresses ideas that are characteristic not of the sultan of a medieval despotic state, but of an educator of the 18th century.

Composition

The philosophical story is a difficult and interesting genre, intellectual game mind, He combines both an essay and a pamphlet, and the author puts forward an idea or laughs at these ideas and events. François-Marie Arouet, known as Voltaire, used the philosophical story genre to teach mankind, to show him what is bad and not safe in him. Pushkin called him "minds and fashion conductor." André Maurois called the masterpieces of Voltaire his "Zadiga", "Candide" and "Simple". He said that Voltaire's style is sheer, and the characters cannot be taken seriously - "you won't even have time to cry ..." Voltaire makes each of his readers think: who is this hero? Does he believe in fate? Or in God? Or a good country outlined by the author? Or is she fair? All these ideas are characteristic of the Enlightenment, when the ideas proclaimed by French Revolution- the ideas of Freedom, Equality, Fraternity. In the story "Simple Man" Voltaire discusses with the theory of "natural man" Jean-Jacques Rousseau. “When you read your work,” he wrote to Rousseau, “you just want to become crustaceans,”

The hero of The Simpleton is the savage Huron, a child of nature. He ended up in the civilized world. We see this "civilized" world through the eyes of common man, he perceives simple things and simple relationships between people, he takes everything literally. Huron does not understand why people confuse everything and do things where there is no common sense. “I spent fifty years on my education, but in terms of common sense it will be hard for me to cope with this half-wild child,” Huron's teacher thinks. In Voltaire's story, this resorts to a fabulous or fantastic plot. The heroes of the story are as real as reality, modern writer. The townsfolk show extraordinary curiosity when they listen to Huron's story. They report a lot of strength to christen the newly found relative. It is here that Voltaire puts into his mouth actors lead a debate about the church and religious tolerance. Mademoiselle does not understand why he is still not a Catholic, as if only the Catholic faith exists in the world. Voltaire puts the answer to this in the mouth of Huron, it is a new idea for that time of freedom of religion: "Everyone in England has the right to live as he wants."

Deciding to voluntarily accept the Catholic faith, Huron studies spiritual works and begins to make appropriate spiritual teaching deeds. Taking quite literally everything that is read in spiritual texts, he, having finished confession for the believer, demands the same confession from the monk, and tries to be baptized in the river, thereby fulfilling the letter of Catholicism. Such situations in which Huron finds himself, invented by Voltaire in order to talk about how meaningless the laws and regulations are in the so-called "civilized" countries. What nonentities Europeans look like in their desire to explain to the savage the dubious advantages of their life. When Huron finds out that in order to marry the woman he loves, their personal vows are not enough, more witnesses, notaries, agreements and permissions are required, he comes to the conclusion: “Probably dishonest people, if you still need warnings ...”, he says.

The hero of Voltaire does not understand the confessional relationship between Catholics and Huguenots, and demands to explain why “such a great king, whose glory reached even those countries of the Hurons, left himself without such a large number of hearts that could love him, and such a large number of hands that could serve him? The stupidity of these discrepancies is even more real today, Voltaire emphasized this three centuries ago. Unfortunately, it is still relevant today. Representatives of different concessions are hostile one to one and cannot unite humanity. From a distant century, the sage of Ferney tells us, people of the twenty-first century, that we should not look for evil in civilization or culture, in science or in price. Evil lies in the immoral structure of society, in the absence of moral principles in people. So, perhaps we will find the answer in Voltaire, who in the Simpleton stated: "Reading raises the soul, and an enlightened friend brings an idea."

Year of writing:

1767

Reading time:

Description of the work:

The philosophical story of Voltaire - "The Innocent" was written in 1767. With their weakness, the main characters evoke empathy. The story was filmed twice, including in Russia in 1994.

We offer your attention summary story Innocent.

On a July evening in 1689, the Abbé de Kerkabon was walking with his sister along the seashore in his small priory in Lower Brittany and reflected on the bitter fate of his brother and his wife, who twenty years ago had sailed from that very coast to Canada and disappeared there forever. At this moment, a ship approaches the bay and disembarks young man in the clothes of an Indian, who appears to be Innocent, because that is what his English friends called him for his sincerity and unfailing honesty. He impresses the venerable prior with courtesy and sanity, and is invited to dinner at the house, where the Innocent is introduced to the local society. The next day, wanting to thank his hosts for their hospitality, the young man gives them a talisman: portraits of unknown people tied on a cord, in which the prior with excitement recognizes his brother-captain and his wife who disappeared in Canada. The simple-hearted did not know his parents, and he was raised by the Huron Indians. Having found a loving uncle and aunt in the person of the prior and his sister, the young man settles in their house.

First of all, the good prior and his neighbors decide to christen the Innocent. But first it was necessary to enlighten him, since it is impossible to convert an adult person to a new religion without his knowledge. The simple-hearted reads the Bible, and thanks to natural understanding, as well as the fact that his childhood was not burdened with trifles and absurdities, his brains perceived all objects in an undistorted form. Godmother, according to the desire of the Innocent, was invited by the charming Mademoiselle de Saint-Yves, the sister of their neighbor, the abbe. However, the sacrament was suddenly threatened, because the young man was sincerely sure that it was possible to be baptized only in the river, following the example of the characters in the Bible. Uncorrupted by convention, he refused to admit that the fashion for baptism could change. With the help of the lovely Sainte-Yves, the Innocent was still persuaded to be baptized in the font. In a tender conversation that followed the baptism, the Innocent and Mademoiselle de Saint-Yves confess their mutual love, and the young man decides to marry immediately. The well-behaved girl had to explain that the rules require permission for the marriage of their relatives, and the Innocent considered this another absurdity: why the happiness of his life should depend on his aunt. But the venerable prior announced to his nephew that, according to divine and human laws, marrying a godmother is a terrible sin. The simple-minded objected that in holy book nothing is said about such stupidity, as well as about many other things that he observed in his new homeland. Nor could he understand why a pope living four hundred leagues away and speaking a foreign language should allow him to marry the girl he loved. He vowed to marry her on the same day, which he tried to carry out by breaking into her room and invoking her promise and his natural right. They began to prove to him that if there were no contractual relations between people, natural law would turn into natural robbery. We need notaries, priests, witnesses, contracts. The simple-minded object that only dishonest people such precautions are necessary. They reassure him by saying that it was just honest and enlightened people who came up with the laws, and how better man, the more obediently he must obey them, in order to set an example for the vicious. At this time, the relatives of Saint-Yves decide to hide her in a monastery in order to marry her to an unloved person, from which the Innocent comes to despair and rage.

In gloomy despondency, the Innocent wanders along the shore, when he suddenly sees a French detachment retreating in panic. It turned out that the English squadron treacherously landed and was going to attack the town. He valiantly rushes at the British, wounds the admiral and inspires the French soldiers to victory. The town was saved, and the Innocent was glorified. In the rapture of battle, he decides to storm the monastery and rescue his bride. He is restrained from this and given advice to go to Versailles to the king, and there to receive a reward for saving the province from the British. After such an honor, no one will be able to prevent him from marrying Mademoiselle de Saint-Yves.

The path of the Innocent to Versailles leads through a small town of Protestants who have just lost all rights after the repeal of the Edict of Nantes and were forcibly converted to Catholicism. The inhabitants leave the city in tears, and the Innocent tries to understand the reason for their misfortunes: why the great king follows the Pope's lead and deprives himself of six hundred thousand loyal citizens to please the Vatican. The simple-hearted is convinced that the intrigues of the Jesuits and unworthy advisers who surrounded the king are to blame. How else could he indulge the pope, his open enemy? The simple-minded promises the inhabitants that, having met the king, he will reveal the truth to him, and having learned the truth, according to the young man, one cannot help but follow it. Unfortunately for him, a disguised Jesuit was present at the table during the conversation, who was a detective with the king's confessor, Father Lachaise, the main persecutor of poor Protestants. The detective scribbled the letter, and the Innocent One arrived at Versailles almost at the same time as this letter. The naive young man sincerely believed that upon arrival he would immediately be able to see the king, tell him about his merits, get permission to marry Saint-Yves and open his eyes to the position of the Huguenots. But with difficulty, the Innocent manages to get an appointment with one court official, who tells him that at best he can buy the rank of lieutenant. The young man is outraged that he still has to pay for the right to risk his life and fight, and promises to complain about the stupid official to the king. The official decides that the Innocent is out of his mind, and does not attach any importance to his words. On this day, Father Lachaise receives letters from his detective and relatives, Mademoiselle Saint-Yves, where the Innocent is called a dangerous troublemaker who incited to burn monasteries and steal girls. At night, the soldiers attack the sleeping young man and, despite his resistance, they are taken to the Bastille, where they are thrown into prison to the imprisoned Jansenist philosopher.

The kindest father Gordon, who later brought so much light and comfort to our hero, was imprisoned without trial for refusing to recognize the pope as the unlimited ruler of France. The old man had great knowledge, and the young man had a great desire to acquire knowledge. Their conversations become more instructive and entertaining, while the naivete and common sense of the Innocent confound the old philosopher. He reads historical books, and history seems to him a continuous chain of crimes and misfortunes. After reading "The Search for Truth" by Malebranche, he decides that everything that exists is the wheels of a huge mechanism, the soul of which is God. God was the cause of both sin and grace. the mind of a young man is strengthened, he masters mathematics, physics, geometry, and at every step he expresses quick wits and a sound mind. He writes down his reasoning, which horrifies the old philosopher. Looking at the Innocent, it seems to Gordon that for half a century of his education he only strengthened prejudices, and the naive young man, heeding only one simple voice nature, was able to come much closer to the truth. Free from deceptive notions, he proclaims the freedom of man as his main right. He condemns the Gordon sect, suffering and persecuted because of disputes not about the truth, but dark delusions, because God has already given all the important truths to people. Gordon understands that he doomed himself to misfortune for the sake of some nonsense, and the Innocent does not find wise those who expose themselves to persecution because of empty scholastic disputes. Thanks to the outpourings of a young man in love, the stern philosopher learned to see in love a noble and tender feeling that can elevate the soul and give rise to virtue. At that time beautiful sweetheart The simple-minded decides to go to Versailles in search of a loved one. She is let out of the convent to be married off, and slips away on the day of the wedding. Once in the royal residence, the poor beauty, in complete confusion, tries to get an appointment with various high-ranking persons, and finally she manages to find out that the Innocent is imprisoned in the Bastille. The official who revealed this to her says with pity that he does not have the power to do good, and he cannot help her. But here is the assistant of the all-powerful minister, M. de Saint-Poinge, who does both good and evil. The favored Sainte-Yves hurries to Sainte-Poinge, who, fascinated by the beauty of the girl, hints that at the cost of her honor she could cancel the order to arrest the Innocent. Friends also push her for the sake of a sacred duty to sacrifice women's honor. Virtue forces her to fall. At the cost of shame, she frees her lover, but exhausted by the consciousness of her sin, the tender Saint-Yves cannot survive the fall, and, seized with a deadly fever, dies in the arms of the Innocent. At this moment, Saint-Puange himself appears, and in a fit of repentance he swears to make amends for the misfortune caused.