Why burned 2 dead souls. Why did Gogol burn the second volume of Dead Souls? A wide variety of opinions and conjectures - why Gogol burned the "dead souls"

Most of the people whose profession is the study of literature, in particular, Nikolai Vasilyevich Gogol, agree that on the night of about February 11-12, a hundred and fifty years ago, the great Ukrainian classic burned the second volume of his work under the slightly creepy title “The Dead souls." Why did he do this and why did Gogol burn the second volume?

A wide variety of opinions and conjectures - why Gogol burned the "dead souls"

There are several points of view on what happened winter night. The first says that there was no second volume initially, something else was burned, some drafts, manuscripts, possibly left after the first volume. The second was originally a fiction.

Others believe that the second volume of the novel really burned in the fireplace, but this was nothing more than an unfortunate accident. And although another classic, Bulgakov, said that manuscripts do not burn, in reality it turned out differently. Nikolai Vasilievich had no choice but to reconcile himself and accept this as a fate. Creative people are known to be superstitious.

There are also such literary scholars who believe that the idea of ​​the second and subsequent, third volume was so grandiose that it was simply impossible to realize it, as a result, the writer burned all his attempts in his hearts. But there was no finished second volume. He could not positively regenerate the main character - Chichikov.

Now the opinion is becoming more and more widespread that already at the time of writing the second volume, Gogol simply stopped admiring Ukraine, which was then called Little Russia, as well as the Cossacks. Consequently, the source of inspiration for the second volume disappeared, and the writer destroyed the miserable attempts, realizing that he would not write anything of the road. But such an assumption is not based on anything concrete, there is not a single fact indicating that Nikolai Gogol did not love his homeland literally to the last breath.

Mystics generally consider the work itself to be a satanic book, therefore, they say, the writer paid for such a name, what is the second volume, when dark forces intervened. But this fiction is as far from the truth as the previous assumption. The fact is that according to the plot there was nothing magical, just like there was nothing mystical, it was about the most ordinary hack-work of officials. They passed off the dead as the living.

Do you know?

• The giraffe is considered the tallest animal in the world, its height reaches 5.5 meters. Mainly due to the long neck. Despite the fact that in […]
• Many will agree that women in position become especially superstitious, they are more subject to all sorts of beliefs and […]
• It is rare to meet a person who would not find rose bush beautiful. But, at the same time, it is common knowledge. That such plants are rather tender […]
• Whoever says with confidence that he does not know that men watch porn films will lie in the most impudent way. Of course, they look, just [...]
• There is probably no such automotive-related site or auto-forum on the World Wide Web that would not ask a question about […]
• The sparrow is a fairly common bird of small size and variegated color in the world. But its peculiarity lies in the fact that […]
• Laughter and tears, or rather, crying, are two directly opposite emotions. What is known about them is that they are both congenital and not […]

On May 21, 1842, the first volume of " dead souls"Nikolai Gogol. The mystery of the second part of the great work, destroyed by the writer, still worries the minds of literary critics and ordinary readers. Why did Gogol burn the manuscript? And did it exist at all? The Moscow Trust TV channel prepared a special report.

That night he again could not sleep, he again and again paced his office in a cozy outbuilding of an old city estate on Nikitsky Boulevard. He tried to pray, lay down again, but could not close his eyes for a second. A chilly February dawn was already dawning outside the windows, when he took a battered briefcase out of the closet, pulled out a plump manuscript tied with twine, held it in his hands for a few seconds, and then resolutely threw the papers into the fireplace.

What happened on the night of February 11-12, 1852 in the mansion of Count Alexander Tolstoy? Why did Gogol, who gained fame as a great writer during his lifetime, decide to destroy, perhaps, the main work of his life? And how is it related tragic event in Russian literature with death, which doctors will fix 10 days later here, next to the fireplace, the flame of which consumed the second volume of the poem "Dead Souls"?

Count Alexander Tolstoy acquired this mansion after the death of its former owner, Major General Alexander Talyzin, a veteran of the war against Napoleon. Nikolai Vasilievich Gogol ended up here in 1847, when he returned to Russia from long-distance wanderings. "He was a traveler: stations, changing horses, he pondered many of his stories on the road. And always, as a creative person, he is looking for communication, in particular with his friends. And regularly one of his friends invited him to his place, to live in Moscow invited Tolstoy, with whom he had been in correspondence until that time, "- says the director of the House N.V. Gogol Vera Vikulova.

The second volume of Dead Souls may have been nearly completed by this point, with only the last few chapters to be edited.

House number 7 on Suvorovsky (Nikitsky) Boulevard, where the great Russian writer N.V. Gogol lived and died. Photo: ITAR-TASS

From the windows of the estate, Nikolai Vasilievich watched his beloved Moscow. Since then, of course, Moscow has changed a lot. The city was completely rural. There was a crane-well in the courtyard of the house, frogs croaked under the windows.

In the estate, the writer was a welcome and honored guest, he was given a whole wing, the main room of which was the office.

As the chief custodian of the House N.V. Gogol, here he lived on everything ready: tea was served to him at any moment, fresh linen, lunch, dinner - there were no worries, all conditions were created for him to work here on the second volume of Dead Souls.

So what happened at dawn on February 12, 1852? What secret does this office keep in house number 7A on Nikitsky Boulevard? Researchers to this day put forward a variety of versions: from Gogol's madness to the crisis he is experiencing.

Gogol treated everyday life and comfort without much interest, as well as everything material. A small couch, a mirror, a bed behind a screen, a desk where he worked. Gogol always wrote standing up, worked carefully over each phrase and sometimes painfully long. Of course, this sacrament required a fair amount of paper. It can be seen from the manuscripts that Gogol was very demanding of himself and said that "my business is not literature, my business is the soul."

Gogol was a merciless critic, and he made the highest, uncompromising demands, first of all, on himself. “Up to seven times he rewrote each chapter, he filigree cleaned up the text so that it would fit well on the ear and at the same time his idea would be interesting to the reader,” says the art manager of the House N.V. Gogol Larisa Kosareva.

The final edition of the second volume of Dead Souls is by no means Gogol's first work to die in a fire. The first he burned while still in the gymnasium. Arriving in St. Petersburg because of criticism of the poem " Ganz Küchelgarten", he buys and burns all copies. He also burns the second volume of Dead Souls, for the first time back in 1845.

Reproduction of the painting "N.V. Gogol listening to a folk musician-kobza player near his house", 1949

This is the first version - perfectionism. Gogol also destroyed the next edition of the second volume of Dead Souls, because he simply did not like it.

The writer Vladislav Otroshenko believes that one can get closer to unraveling the mystery of the fireplace in the mansion on Nikitsky Boulevard only by thoroughly studying the character traits of the great writer, including those that even contemporaries were at least perplexed, especially in last years Gogol's life. In the middle of a conversation, he could suddenly say: "Okay, that's it, we'll talk later," lie down on the sofa and turn to the wall. The manner of his communication irritated many of his friends and relatives.

One of Gogol's most inexplicable habits is his penchant for hoaxes. Even in the most innocent situations, he often did not finish speaking, misled the interlocutor, or even lied at all. Vladislav Otroshenko wrote: “Gogol said: “You must never tell the truth. If you're going to Rome, say you're going to Kaluga, if you're going to Kaluga, say you're going to Rome." This nature of Gogol's deceit remains incomprehensible both for literary critics and for those who study Gogol's biography."

Nikolai Vasilyevich also had a special relationship with his own passport: every time he crossed the border of a state, he categorically refused to show the document to the border service. For example, they stopped a stagecoach, they said: "You must show your passport." Gogol turns away and pretends not to understand what he is being told. And friends are at a loss, they say: "They won't let us through." Then, in the end, he starts rummaging, as if looking for a passport, but everyone knows who is traveling with him, that the passport is in his pocket.

"He wrote letters, for example, to his mother, who is now in Trieste, sees the beautiful waves of the Mediterranean Sea, enjoys the views, describes Trieste in detail to her. He did not just write her a letter signed "Trieste" (written, in fact, in the estate of his friend, historian Mikhail Pogodin, in Moscow on Devichye Pole), he also drew a stamp of Trieste on the letter. He carefully deduced it so that it was impossible to distinguish, "says Vladislav Otroshenko, who wrote a book about Gogol for five years.

So, version two: the burning of the second volume of "Dead Souls" was another eccentric trick of a genius who did so much for Russian literature that he could afford almost everything. He knew very well that he was popular among his contemporaries and that he was the No. 1 writer.

Etching "Gogol reads The Government Inspector" to the writers and artists of the Maly Theatre, 1959. Photo: ITAR-TASS

It is also surprising that even before the advent of the era of photography, Gogol was known by sight. An ordinary walk along your favorite Moscow boulevards turned almost into a spy detective. The students of Moscow University, knowing that Gogol likes to walk along Nikitsky and Tverskoy boulevards in the afternoon, left the lectures with the words: "We are going to look at Gogol." According to the memoirs, the writer was not tall, about 1.65 meters, he often wrapped himself in an overcoat, maybe from the cold, or maybe to be less recognized.

Gogol had a great many admirers, they not only took for granted any oddities of their idol, but were also ready to indulge him in everything. Bread balls, which the writer had a habit of rolling, thinking about something, became the object of desire for collectors, fans constantly followed Gogol and picked up balls, kept them as relics.

Director Kirill Serebrennikov has his own view of Gogol's work. He is ready to pose the question even more radically: did the second volume of "Dead Souls" exist at all? Maybe the brilliant hoaxer tricked everyone here?

Specialists who thoroughly study the life and work of Gogol partly agree with the version of the radical director. great writer was ready to mystify anything.

Once, when Gogol was visiting Sergei Aksakov, he was visited by close friend, actor Mikhail Shchepkin. The writer enthusiastically told the guest that he had finished the second volume of Dead Souls. One can only guess how delighted Shchepkin was: he was the first to be lucky enough to find out that the grandiose plan was completed. Final of this strange story did not take long to wait: the orderly Moscow company, which usually gathered at Aksakov's, had just sat down at the dinner table. Shchepkin gets up with a glass of wine and says: “Gentlemen, congratulate Nikolai Vasilyevich, he finished the second volume of Dead Souls.” And then Gogol jumps up and says: “Who did you hear this from?” Shchepkin replies: “Yes, from you, today in the morning you told me. " To which Gogol reacted: "You overate henbane, or you dreamed." The guests laughed: indeed, Shchepkin came up with something there.

Acting attracted Gogol with an almost irresistible force: before writing down something, Gogol played it out in their faces. And surprisingly, there were no guests, Gogol was alone, but they sounded completely different voices, male, female, Gogol was a brilliant actor.

Once, already being quite famous writer, he even tried to get a job in Alexandrinsky Theater. At the audition, Gogol received an offer only to call the audience and arrange chairs. Interestingly, a couple of months after this interview, the head of the troupe was instructed to prepare Gogol's "Inspector General".

Gogol's wanderlust became one of the topics interactive tour, which takes place every day in the house-museum on Nikitsky Boulevard. Visitors are greeted by an old travel chest, the impression is enhanced by the sounds of the road coming from its depths.

As you know, Gogol was more often in Europe than in Russia. Actually, he wrote the first volume of "Dead Souls" in Italy, where he spent a total of 12 years and which he called his second homeland. It was from Rome that a letter once arrived that made Gogol's friends seriously alert. One gets the feeling that Gogol in his life begins to play out the story with the nose of Major Kovalev. As the nose separated from Major Kovalev and began to walk on its own, so it is here. Gogol wrote in his letters that it was necessary to find some other Gogol in St. Petersburg, that some fraudulent stories might happen, some works might be published under his name.

It was then that the idea crept in that Gogol's endless hoaxes were not just an eccentricity of a genius, but a symptom of a deeply mental illness.

One of the researchers at the House N.V. Gogol says: “I once led a tour of psychiatrists. I didn’t know that they were psychiatrists, so I told them my opinion. But they told me: “Yes, we have already diagnosed Gogol a long time ago. Well, even look at the handwriting, "- in the museum on the desk there are samples of Gogol's handwriting. They began to say directly what kind of disorder it was. But it seems to me that not every doctor would risk making a diagnosis in absentia, but here 200 years ago."

Maybe the burning of the second volume of "Dead Souls" was indeed an insane act in the clinical sense of the word? So, attempts to understand and explain it from the point of view of common sense is an empty and useless exercise?

But this version is by no means the last one. It is known that the author of the mystical "Evenings on a Farm near Dikanka" and the completely infernal "Viya" at the end of his life denied any devilry. At this time, Gogol was often seen in the church of Nicholas the Wonderworker (Gogol's spiritual patron) in Starovagankovsky Lane.

Drawing by Boris Lebedev "Meeting Gogol with Belinsky", 1948. Photo: ITAR-TASS

Some researchers believe that it was truly fatal (both for the second volume of Dead Souls and for their creator) to meet Archpriest Matvey Konstantinovsky, the spiritual mentor of Count Alexander Tolstoy. The priest, who was distinguished by extreme sharpness of judgment, eventually became Gogol's confessor. He showed his manuscript, on which he had been working for nine years, to Father Matvey, and received negative reviews. It is possible that these cruel words priest and steel last straw. On the night of February 11-12, 1852, the guest of the house on Nikitsky Boulevard committed what the artist Ilya Repin would later call "Gogol's self-immolation." It is believed that Gogol burned it in a state of passion and later regretted it immensely, but he was consoled by the owner of the house, Alexander Petrovich Tolstoy. He came up and said quietly: "But you have everything here, in your head, you can restore it."

But the restoration of the second volume was out of the question. The next day, Gogol announced that he was beginning to fast, and soon refused food altogether. He fasted with such zeal, with which, probably, no one of the believers fasted. And at some point, when it was clear that Gogol was already weakening, Count Tolstoy called for doctors, they did not find any illness in Gogol.
10 days later Gogol died of physical exhaustion. The death of the great writer shocked Moscow, in the church of the Holy Martyr Tatyana at Moscow University, it seemed, the whole city said goodbye to him. All adjacent streets were filled with people, farewell went on for a very long time.

It was decided to erect a monument to Gogol in Moscow 30 years later, in the early 80s 19th century. The collection of donations was delayed, the required amount was collected only by 1896. Several competitions were held, for which more than fifty projects were submitted. As a result, the monument was entrusted to the young sculptor Nikolai Andreev. He took up the task with his characteristic thoroughness. Andreev was always looking for nature for his works. He studied every possible portrait of Gogol that he could find. He painted, portrayed Gogol, using the services of his brother, who posed for him for sculpture.

The sculptor visited the writer's homeland, met with his younger sister. The result of his fundamental research was, without exaggeration, a monument revolutionary for that time. In 1909, the monument on Arbat Square was opened in front of a crowd of thousands.

Even the laying of the monument was very solemn and celebrated in the restaurant "Prague". The organizers came up with a very original approach to the gala dinner, because they prepared all the dishes that somehow appeared in Gogol's works: this is "soup in a saucepan from Paris", and "shaneshki with salt" from Korobochka, and various pickles, jams from the bins Pulcheria Ivanovna.

However, not everyone liked the sad, thoughtful, tragic Gogol. They say that, in the end, the monument was moved from Arbat Square to the courtyard of the estate of Count Tolstoy on the orders of Stalin himself. And in 1952, at the beginning of Gogolevsky Boulevard, a poster appeared, full of health, Nikolai Vasilevich, equipped with a pathos inscription: “To Gogol from the Government Soviet Union". The new, retouched image gave rise to many ridicule: "Gogol's humor is dear to us, Gogol's tears are a hindrance. He made me sad while sitting, let this one stand for laughter."

However, over time, Muscovites fell in love with this image. In the late 70s of the last century, Moscow hippies began to gather around the monument on Gogolevsky Boulevard. The era of flower children is long gone, but every year on April 1, the aged Moscow "khipari", putting on their favorite bell-bottoms, gather again on the "gogols" to remember their cheerful youth. Hippies have their own answer to every question, their own truth and their own mythology. And Nikolai Vasilievich Gogol in their pantheon occupies a special, but undoubtedly very place of honor. The artist Alexander Iosifov remarked: “Firstly, Gogol himself already has a hippie look. Secondly, he is to some extent mystically predisposed to the perception of life, to which those young people are also predisposed. It is such an inadequate perception of life.”

And, of course, every hippie has his own version of what happened in the house on Nikitsky Boulevard: “He was disappointed in life. Plus, they say he was very sick, and according to legend, when the coffin was opened, his lid was scratched. Maybe He must have been buried alive."

The halo of mystery that surrounded Gogol during his lifetime only deepened after his death. Vladislav Otroshenko believes that this is natural: “Before Gogol, we never had a writer who would make literature his life. Here is Pushkin - yes, he had a lot of things in life: he had a family, a wife, children, duels, cards ", friends, court intrigues. Gogol had nothing in his life but literature. Here he was such a monk of literature."

A monk, an ascetic, an eccentric hermit, a hypocrite and a lone traveler, a writer who left the greatest legacy and did not have even elementary signs of life during his lifetime. After the death of the writer, an inventory was compiled, mainly books were his property, 234 volumes - this is both in Russian and in foreign languages. The clothes listed in this inventory were in a deplorable state. Of all the valuable things, only a gold watch can be named. "The watch, however, disappeared. And what has survived has come down to us thanks to friends, relatives or simply admirers of writing talent. The main pride of the House of N.V. Gogol is a glass purchased from descendants on the line of sister Elizabeth, which Nikolai Vasilyevich gave her for her wedding. Also in the museum there is a needle case made of bone, which passed to him from his mother. Nikolai Vasilyevich, it turns out, sewed and embroidered very well, he straightened his ties, scarves, and also sewed sister dresses.

Admirers of Gogol's melodious style still come to this house on Nikitsky Boulevard today. Every year in March, the writer's memorial day is celebrated here, and every time "Prayer" is heard - the only poem by Gogol. In this house during the life of Gogol, Gogol's Ukrainian Wednesdays were held. Gogol was very fond of the Ukrainian song, and although he himself did not have such a pronounced ear for music but collected Ukrainian songs, wrote them down and loved to sing along and even lightly stamp his foot.

Painting by Pyotr Geller "Gogol, Pushkin and Zhukovsky in the summer of 1831 in Tsarskoe Selo", 1952. Photo: ITAR-TASS

Everyone can come to the house on Nikitsky Boulevard, but not everyone can stay. Vera Nikulina (Director of the House of N.V. Gogol) says: "I had cases when people came, worked for three days, their temperature rose, did not fall, and they left. It is believed that the house accepts or does not accept a person." Some clarify: this is not a house, but Gogol himself tests people for strength, greets the faithful and resolutely brushes aside the casual ones. The following saying appeared in the Gogol House: "this is Gogol." How something happens - "it's Gogol's fault."

So what happened to Gogol on the night of February 11-12, 1852? The writer Vladislav Otroshenko is sure that these pages of a plump manuscript rapidly turning into ashes are only the last act of the tragedy that began ten years earlier, at the very moment when the first volume of the poem "Dead Souls" saw the light of day: "All Russia is waiting for him to souls "when the first volume makes a revolution in Russian literature and in the minds of readers. All of Russia looks at him, and he soars above the world. And suddenly a crash. He writes to the maid of honor of the court Alexandra Osipovna Smirnova, she was one of his close friends, in 1845 He writes to her: "God took away from me the ability to create."

This version does not deny all the previous ones, rather, it combines them together, and therefore seems to be the most probable. Vladislav Otroshenko: “Gogol died from literature, died from Dead Souls, because it was such a thing that it either is written and elevates the creator simply to heaven, or it kills him if it is not written. After all, Gogol intended to write a third volume , and there were only two ways to get out of this grandiose plan - either to commit it or to die.

Gogol for a century and a half remains one of the most mystery writers. Sometimes bright and ironic, more often - gloomy, half-mad, and always - magical and elusive. And therefore, everyone who opens his books every time finds something of their own in them.

Larisa Kosareva (art manager of the House of N.V. Gogol): "Mystery, mysticism, mystery, humor - what is missing in modern prose. Still, he is very ironic, and this joke, humor, fantasy is a blockbuster of the 19th century, Gogol.

One Byron (actor): "Very similar to our poet Edgar Allan Poe. Here is a common dark side, I think. Man with difficult fate, both of these poets had complex life plots. They both love the moment of the absurd. I love the absurd."

Vladislav Otroshenko (writer): "We always say that literature is generally the most important wealth that Russia had, wealth that does not dry out. Because the attitude, which, by the way, was set by Gogol, the attitude to literature as to what something that swallows you whole."

Collected works of N.V. Gogol, 1975. Photo: ITAR-TASS

And therefore, probably, every thoughtful reader has his own version of what actually happened on a February night in a house on Nikitsky Boulevard.

Museum researcher Oleg Robinov believes that shortly before his death, Nikolai Vasilyevich came and buried the second volume of "Dead Souls" in his yard. Moreover, he made an embankment, a small mound, and told the peasants, bequeathed that if there is a lean year, you will dig it up, sell it, and you will be happy.

February 24, 1852 Nikolay Gogol burned the almost finished second volume of Dead Souls, on which he had been working for more than 10 years. The story itself was originally conceived by Gogol as a trilogy. In the first volume, the adventurer Chichikov, traveling through Russia, encountered only human vices, in the second part, fate brought the protagonist together with some positive characters. In the third volume, which was never written, Chichikov had to go through exile in Siberia and finally embark on the path of moral purification.

AiF.ru tells why Gogol burned the second volume of "Dead Souls" and what adventures in the continuation of the story were to happen to Chichikov.

Most likely, Gogol burned the second volume of Dead Souls by accident. In the last years of his life, the writer felt constant weakness in the body, but instead of being treated, he continued to exhaust his body with strict adherence to religious fasts and exhausting work. In one of the letters to poet Nikolai Yazykov Gogol wrote: "My health has become rather poor ... Nervous anxious anxiety and various signs of perfect unsticking all over my body frighten me myself." It is possible that this “sticking up” prompted the writer on the night of February 24 to throw the manuscripts into the fireplace and then set them on fire with his own hands. The servant witnessed this scene Semyon, who persuaded the master to spare the papers. But he only rudely replied: “None of your business! Pray!

In the morning next day Gogol, struck by his act, lamented his friendCount Alexander Tolstoy: "That's what I did! I wanted to burn some things that had long been prepared for that, but I burned everything. How strong the evil one is - that's what he moved me to! And I was there a lot of practical clarified and outlined ... I thought to send to friends as a keepsake from a notebook: let them do what they wanted. Now everything is gone."

Gogol claimed that he wanted to burn only drafts and unnecessary papers, and the second volume of Dead Souls was sent to the fireplace due to his oversight. Nine days after this fatal mistake, the writer died.

Gogol's letters and the remaining drafts allow us to restore the approximate content of some parts of the burnt manuscript. The second volume of "Dead Souls" begins with a description of the estate of Andrei Ivanovich Tentetnikov, whom the author calls "the smoker of the sky." An educated and fair person, due to laziness and lack of willpower, drags out a meaningless existence in the village. Tentetnikov's fiancee, Ulinka, is the daughter of a neighboring general, Betrishchev. It is she who becomes "a ray of light in dark kingdom story: “If a transparent picture suddenly flared up in a dark room, lit from behind by a lamp, it would not have struck like this figurine, shining with life, which appeared exactly to light up the room ... It was difficult to say what land she was born in . Such a pure, noble outline of the face could not be found anywhere, except perhaps only on some ancient cameos, ”Gogol describes it this way. Tentetnikov, according to Gogol's plan, was to be convicted for participation in an anti-government organization, and his lover would follow him to hard labor. Then, in the third volume of the trilogy, these heroes had to go through exile in Siberia along with Chichikov.

Further, according to the plot of the second volume, Chichikov meets the bored landowner Platonov and, having incited him to travel together in Russia, goes to the master Kostanzhoglo, who is married to Platonov's sister. He talks about the ways of managing, by which he increased the income from the estate tenfold, which Chichikov is terribly inspired by. Shortly thereafter, Chichikov, having borrowed money from Platonov and Kostanjoglo, is trying to buy the estate from the ruined landowner Khlobuev.

On the "border line" between good and evil in the second volume of the story, the financier Afanasy Murazov suddenly appears. He wants to spend 40 million rubles earned by him not in the most honest way on “saving Russia”, but his ideas are more reminiscent of sectarian ones.

In the surviving drafts of the end of the manuscript, Chichikov is found in the city at a fair, where he buys fabric of a lingonberry color so dear to him with a spark. He runs into Khlobuev, whom, apparently, he “gave up”, either by depriving, or almost depriving him of his estate by forgery. Murazov saves Chichikov from continuing an unpleasant conversation, who convinces the ruined landowner of the need to work and determines him to raise funds for the church. Meanwhile, denunciations are being found against Chichikov both about forgery and about dead souls. However, the help of the corrupt official Samosvistov and the intercession of Murazov allow the hero to avoid prison.

Poem (this genre of his work was designated by the author) N.V. Gogol's Dead Souls is one of classical works Russian literature. And the story that happened with the second volume of this work is known even to those who have never opened the first volume. Literary scholars (despite disagreements about the “strength” or “weakness” of the second volume) agree on one thing - the destruction by Gogol of the second volume of Dead Souls that he had already written is one of the most serious losses in our literature. Question: Why did the gogol burn the second tome of the dead souls?", - arose immediately after the incident, and there is still no single and unequivocal answer to it. And with the burning itself, not everything is clear. As they say, was there a boy?

Version one: Gogol did not burn anything, since the second volume of Dead Souls did not exist

This version relies on the fact that no one has seen the finished manuscript of the second volume of the poem, and the only witness to the burning was Gogol's servant Semyon. It is from his words that we know what happened that night. Allegedly, the writer ordered Semyon to bring a briefcase in which notebooks with the continuation of Dead Souls were kept. Gogol put the notebooks in the fireplace and set fire to them with a candle, and to the servant’s pleas not to destroy the manuscript he said: “None of your business! Pray! Semyon, on the other hand, was quite young, illiterate and could well spin nonsense (if it is simple). This version is not taken seriously by most researchers. The surviving drafts of the work and the testimonies of contemporaries give grounds to assert that the "white" version did exist.

Version two: Gogol burned the drafts, and the manuscript of the second volume of Dead Souls came (after the death of the writer) to Count A.P. Tolstoy, with whom Gogol lived at that time.

This version is also based on the unreliability of the testimony of Semyon's servant and is also considered unlikely. A. Tolstoy had no reason to hide the manuscript, but even if he had done so, the manuscript would certainly have "surfaced" since then.

Version three: Gogol really burned the second volume of Dead Souls, as he was dissatisfied with it and was in a clouded state of mind.

This version seems more likely, since the writer's mental health at that moment was far from brilliant. Gogol suffered from seizures from childhood, accompanied by melancholy and depression. In January 1852, E. Khomyakova, the wife of Gogol's friend, died, and this event had an extremely detrimental effect on the writer. The writer was tormented by a constant fear of death, and his confessor urged him to abandon literary work, which Gogol himself considered his only vocation. Of course, it is difficult to make diagnoses now, but it is obvious that the writer's mind was, if not clouded, then on the verge of clouding. It is likely that in a fit of self-flagellation, he could consider his work insignificant and not deserving to be published. However, dominating this moment considered a different version.

Version four: Gogol wanted to burn the drafts, however, being in a state of complete mental exhaustion, he confused them with the white version.

It is believed that Semyon's story, if not absolutely accurate, is close to the truth, but the writer had no intention of burning the final version. Supporters of this version cite Gogol's words, which he said the next morning to Count Tolstoy: "That's what I did! I wanted to burn some things that had been prepared for a long time, but I burned everything. How strong the crafty one is - that's what he pushed me to! And I was there I figured out and explained a lot of useful things ... I thought about sending them to my friends as a keepsake from a notebook: let them do what they wanted. Now everything is gone. " It is also believed that in general, with the exception of moments of depression, Gogol was pleased with what he wrote. Although when working on the second volume, the significance of the work in the writer's mind grew beyond the boundaries of the literary texts which made the idea practically unrealizable.

Despite the fact that Gogol burned the manuscript final version the second volume of the poem, rough notes remain. Currently the most complete manuscript The first five chapters of the second volume belong to the American businessman of Russian origin Timur Abdullayev. She had to enter complete collection works and letters of the writer, published in 2010, but for unknown reasons this did not happen. Nevertheless, the question: "Why did Gogol burn the second volume of Dead Souls" is not completely resolved, although there is the most probable version.

Gogol lived by his creativity, for the sake of it he doomed himself to poverty. All his possessions were limited to "the smallest suitcase."

The second volume of "Dead Souls", the main work of the writer's life, the result of his religious quest, was to be completed soon. It was a work in which he put the whole truth about Russia, all his love for her. “My work is great, my feat is saving!” Gogol told his friends.

However, a turning point came in the life of the writer ...

It all started in January 1852, when E. Khomyakova, the wife of Gogol's friend, died. He considered her a worthy woman. And after her death, he confessed to his confessor, Archpriest Matthew (Konstantinovsky): “The fear of death came upon me.” From that moment on, Nikolai Vasilievich constantly thought about death, complained of a breakdown.

All the same Father Matthew demanded that he leave literary works and, finally, think about your spiritual state, moderate your appetite and start fasting. Nikolai Vasilyevich, listening to the advice of his confessor, began to fast, although he did not lose his usual appetite, therefore he suffered from a lack of food, prayed at night, and slept little.

From the point of view of modern psychiatry, it can be assumed that Gogol had a psychoneurosis. Whether the death of Khomyakova had such a strong effect on him, or whether there was some other reason for the development of a neurosis in the writer, is unknown.

But it is known that in childhood Gogol had seizures, which were accompanied by melancholy and depression, so strong that he once said: “To hang myself or drown seemed to me like some kind of medicine and relief.”

And in 1845, in a letter to N.M. Yazykov, Gogol wrote: “My health has become rather poor ... Nervous anxiety and various signs of perfect unsticking all over my body frighten me myself.”

It is possible that exactly the same “sticking up” prompted Nikolai Vasilyevich to commit the strangest act in his biography. On the night of February 11-12, 1852, he called Semyon to him and ordered to bring a briefcase in which notebooks with the continuation of Dead Souls were kept. Under the pleas of the servant not to destroy the manuscript, Gogol put the notebooks in the fireplace and set fire to them with a candle, and Semyon said: “None of your business! Pray!

In the morning, Gogol, apparently himself struck by his impulse, said to Count Tolstoy: “That's what I did! I wanted to burn some things that had been prepared for a long time, but I burned everything. How strong the evil one is - that's what he moved me to! And I was there a lot of practical clarified and outlined ... I thought to send to friends as a keepsake from a notebook: let them do what they wanted. Now everything is gone."